TL;DR
Hunker’s Rob Johnstone tested a solution made from pre-1982 pennies, white vinegar and hydrogen peroxide on oak, cherry and maple. He reported stronger color changes on tannin-rich oak and cherry than on maple, and said the method is a chemical treatment rather than a conventional pigment stain.
Hunker woodworking writer Rob Johnstone tested a wood-coloring mixture made from pre-1982 pennies, white vinegar and hydrogen peroxide, reporting a stronger color change on oak and cherry than on maple. The test gives DIY woodworkers a practical result to weigh before trying the method, but the mixture is a chemical treatment that reacts with wood tannins, not a conventional pigment stain.
Get cleaning gear delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
For the test, Johnstone placed pre-1982 pennies in a glass jar, covered them with white vinegar and left them to soak for about an hour. He then added a couple of tablespoons of hydrogen peroxide and let the mixture stand for three days. Johnstone described the resulting liquid as blue. The source does not give a precise penny count or a measured volume of vinegar, so the recipe is not a fully standardized formula.
Johnstone applied the mixture to oak, cherry and maple after preparing the wood surface. He let it sit for about ten minutes, wiped it off and allowed the wood to dry. After drying, he wiped the surface with a water-soaked cloth to remove vinegar residue, then used a fine synthetic abrasive pad to smooth fibers raised during the process. He said a topcoat could be applied afterward and described using a shellac sealer before a clear finish.
The reported results depended on the wood. Johnstone found that the treatment produced a more pronounced change on tannin-rich oak and cherry, while maple reacted less strongly. He said he liked the appearance on oak and cherry but not on maple. Those are his observations and preferences from this test, not a guarantee of identical results on other boards, preparations or batches of solution.
Wood Species Shape the Result
The test matters to DIYers because the recipe does not offer a uniform color across all wood. Johnstone linked the stronger effect on oak and cherry to their higher tannin content: the solution reacts with tannins in the wood, so species with more tannins can show a more substantial color change. Wood choice is a key variable, and a small test on an offcut can help reveal whether the result suits a project before the mixture is applied to a visible surface.
The method may appeal to people looking to color wood using materials they already have, but it is not interchangeable with a standard stain. Conventional stains typically use pigment suspended in oil- or water-based liquid; in this test, the color change came from a chemical reaction within the wood fibers. The difference affects how readers should set expectations: the outcome may vary with the wood and surface preparation, and the source does not establish a repeatable color specification.
Products Worth Considering

Dyson V15 Detect Cordless Vacuum

TCL 55-Inch T7 Series 4K QLED Smart Google TV, 55T7

Philips Hue Smart Light Starter Kit with Bridge and 4 White and Color A19 Bulbs
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
How the Penny Mixture Works
Johnstone wrote that he had previously used vinegar mixtures involving steel wool or nails to color wood, but had not tried pennies this way. He said pre-1982 pennies were needed because, according to the report, they contain enough copper for the method to work properly. The article also says copper piping may work better, but presents that as an untested possibility rather than a result of Johnstone’s reported comparison.
In Johnstone’s account, vinegar provides the acidic liquid and hydrogen peroxide helps oxidize the copper. The resulting solution then reacts with tannins in the wood. He also notes that untreated wood can change color when exposed to vinegar, which means the final appearance may involve more than one factor. The reported procedure used surface preparation before application, followed by drying, a water wipe and light abrasion before finishing.
“The penny thing was new to me, as was the color of the liquid it produced — a lovely blue color.”
— Rob Johnstone, Hunker woodworking writer
Recipe Limits and Open Questions
The report does not specify an exact number of pennies, a measured amount of vinegar or the concentration of hydrogen peroxide. It also does not report repeated trials, color measurements or tests across different boards of the same species. That leaves batch consistency and repeatability unclear, as well as how factors such as wood source, cut, surface preparation and prior treatment might affect the result.
Johnstone said pre-1982 pennies are needed for sufficient copper content, but the article does not provide a composition test or compare the mixture against newer coins. Its suggestion that copper piping may work better is not backed by a reported side-by-side test. The source also does not give a detailed safety assessment for making or handling the mixture. Readers should follow the product labels for vinegar and hydrogen peroxide, avoid ingesting or mixing the solution with other chemicals, and test it on scrap wood before using it on a finished project.
Test Before Applying a Finish
The Hunker report does not identify a follow-up test or a planned update. For readers considering the technique, the practical next step is to prepare a sample from the same wood as the project and use the intended sanding and application process. Check the dried color before proceeding, since Johnstone’s results varied between oak, cherry and maple.
After application, Johnstone’s process calls for wiping away residue, allowing the wood to dry and smoothing raised fibers before applying a finish. He recommends a shellac sealer as his preference, while saying other clear film finishes can be used. The report does not compare those finishes or establish how the mixture performs over time, so the final appearance and durability of a specific project remain untested in the published account.
Key Questions
What ingredients did Hunker use?
Rob Johnstone used pre-1982 pennies, white vinegar and hydrogen peroxide. He covered the pennies with vinegar, waited about an hour, added a couple of tablespoons of peroxide and let the mixture sit for three days. The report does not give an exact penny count or vinegar volume.
Which woods showed the strongest color change?
Johnstone reported stronger results on oak and cherry than on maple. He attributed the difference to the higher tannin content in oak and cherry. The result may vary, and the report does not establish a standard color for each species.
Is the mixture a conventional wood stain?
Not in the technical sense described by Johnstone. A conventional stain uses pigment suspended in a liquid; this mixture produces color through a reaction with tannins in the wood. The article uses “stain” in the everyday sense of a product that changes wood color.
Can newer pennies be used?
The Hunker report says the method needs pre-1982 pennies because they have sufficient copper content. It does not report a direct test of newer coins, so it does not establish how they would perform.
Should I use it on a finished project right away?
Johnstone tested the mixture on prepared wood and reported different results by species. A scrap-wood test using the same wood and preparation is prudent before treating a visible project surface. The source does not provide a complete safety evaluation or long-term durability comparison.
Source: hunker.com
